A Legacy Forged in Polymer
In the world of handguns, few names command the same level of respect and recognition as the Glock 17. Revered for its reliability, ease of use, and exceptional track record, the Glock 17 has become a staple in law enforcement, military, and civilian self-defense arsenals worldwide. But as Glock continues to innovate, the question arises: which generation reigns supreme? This article dives deep into the Gen model versus the Gen model of the iconic Glock 17, offering a comprehensive comparison to help you determine which is the better fit for your needs.
The story of the Glock 17 begins with an Austrian engineer, Gaston Glock, who revolutionized the firearms industry with his innovative approach to handgun design. Before the Glock 17, handguns were largely crafted from steel, with complex mechanisms and requiring significant maintenance. Glock, however, embraced the use of polymers, making his handguns lighter, more durable, and remarkably resistant to corrosion. The original Glock 17, introduced in the early eighties, quickly gained popularity for its simplicity, safety features, and rugged construction.
This initial model, and its subsequent generations, established a new standard for reliability and performance. The Glock 17 became the foundation for a whole family of Glock handguns, each building on the strengths of the original design while evolving to incorporate improvements and address user feedback. From its inception, the Glock 17 has been a symbol of modern handgun technology.
Evolving the Formula: The Core Differences
The evolution of the Glock 17 didn’t happen overnight. Each generation brought specific enhancements that aimed to improve performance and the shooting experience. These modifications resulted in two notable models in this comparison, the Gen and Gen. Understanding these changes is key to choosing the right handgun. Let’s break down the key areas where these models differ.
Grip and Hand Feel – The Foundation of Control
The grip is arguably the most fundamental aspect of any handgun, as it’s the direct point of contact between the shooter and the weapon. Both generations aim to provide a comfortable and secure grip, but they approach it in distinct ways.
The Gen introduced finger grooves into the grip design. These grooves were intended to help index the hand and provide a more secure hold for the shooter. They were meant to improve ergonomics. However, not everyone found them to be a perfect fit. Hand sizes and individual preferences vary, and some shooters found that the finger grooves didn’t align perfectly with their fingers, leading to a less-than-ideal grip. Furthermore, the Gen came equipped with interchangeable backstraps. These backstraps allowed users to slightly alter the grip size, offering a degree of customization to fit various hand sizes.
The Gen took a different approach. Instead of finger grooves, the Gen abandoned them in favor of a more streamlined grip design. It opted for a more textured grip surface called the Rough Texture Frame (RTF). The RTF provided enhanced grip, and felt more aggressive than the previous generation, especially when wet. Moreover, the Gen features a slightly flared magazine well, making magazine changes easier. This subtle change also contributes to an improved overall handling experience.
The choice between these two grip designs ultimately comes down to personal preference. The Gen with its finger grooves may be a better fit for those who find the grooves comfortable. The Gen, with its simplified design and RTF, could be a more universal choice, offering a better grip for a wider range of users.
Slide Controls and the Flow of Action
The slide is the heart of the handgun’s operation, and the controls for manipulating it are critical for safe and efficient use. Both generations share the same basic slide operation, but some important refinements make the Gen more user-friendly.
The Gen retained the classic slide release lever. This lever has been a standard on Glock handguns for many years, and most experienced shooters are comfortable with its use.
The Gen made a significant change by introducing an ambidextrous slide release. This feature allows both left- and right-handed shooters to easily manipulate the slide release. The slide itself also saw some improvements in terms of finish and durability, enhancing its resistance to wear and tear.
For those who prioritize ambidextrous controls, the Gen has a clear advantage. It greatly simplifies operation and increases speed for both right- and left-handed shooters.
Trigger System – Precision at Your Fingertips
The trigger is the link between the shooter’s intention and the handgun’s performance. A well-designed trigger can significantly enhance accuracy and control.
The Gen utilized the standard Glock trigger system. The pull is smooth and consistent, offering a degree of reliability.
The Gen featured an improved trigger mechanism. This improvement resulted in a cleaner, more defined trigger pull. The new trigger feel can make it easier to shoot accurately. Some users report that it’s a lighter, crisper break.
The trigger upgrades in the Gen are a real advantage for many shooters.
Magazine Release – Speed and Efficiency
Magazine changes are critical for fast reloads. The magazine release is an important component of the handgun’s ergonomics.
The Gen came equipped with the traditional magazine release. The release is reversible, meaning that it can be switched from one side of the gun to the other to accommodate both right- and left-handed shooters.
The Gen boasts a magazine release that is larger and more easily accessible. The enlargement of the magazine release allows for faster reloads.
The Gen offers a distinct advantage in the realm of magazine changes.
Barrel – The Core of Accuracy
The barrel plays a vital role in how accurately the handgun shoots. The barrel is the component that guides the bullet and imparts the spin needed for stable flight.
The Gen came equipped with the standard Glock barrel. This barrel offers acceptable accuracy.
The Gen comes equipped with the Glock Marksman barrel. This barrel is designed for enhanced accuracy. The Marksman barrel includes a more precise rifling profile.
The Marksman barrel gives the Gen a slight accuracy advantage.
Recoil Management – Keeping Control
Recoil is the force that the handgun generates after firing a round. Managing this force is essential for follow-up shots and maintaining control.
The Gen featured a dual recoil spring assembly. This mechanism helps mitigate recoil.
The Gen uses a refined dual recoil spring assembly. This component is a slightly modified version of what’s in the Gen.
Pros and Cons of Each Model
To help you make a decision, let’s summarize the strengths and weaknesses of each model.
Gen
Pros:
- More affordable than the Gen.
- Interchangeable backstraps for grip customization.
- Familiar design for those already accustomed to Glock handguns.
Cons:
- Finger grooves may not fit all hand sizes.
- Trigger pull can be less refined.
- Slide release only for right-handed shooters.
Gen
Pros:
- Improved trigger pull.
- Ambidextrous slide release.
- Enhanced grip texture for better handling.
- Marksman barrel for increased accuracy.
Cons:
- Can be more expensive.
- Grip design may take some getting used to.
Real-World Applications: A Guide for Your Needs
The choice between the Gen and Gen Glock 17 depends largely on how you intend to use the handgun.
- Concealed Carry: Both generations are suitable for concealed carry, but the Gen’s grip design could provide more comfort for some. The Gen’s ambidextrous controls are also a benefit for quick access.
- Duty Use: For law enforcement or military personnel, the Gen’s ambidextrous slide release is a significant advantage, especially for left-handed users. The Marksman barrel and improved trigger of the Gen provide additional benefits.
- Competition Shooting: Competition shooters often value features that enhance speed and accuracy, such as the Gen’s improved trigger and Marksman barrel.
- Home Defense: Both models are excellent choices for home defense. Consider the Gen if you prioritize ambidextrous controls and trigger feel.
- Customization: Aftermarket parts are readily available for both models, offering a vast range of customization options.
A Verdict for Your Choice
Choosing between the Gen and Gen Glock 17 is a matter of individual requirements. Both models have a lot to offer.
The Gen, with its more modern design, ambidextrous controls, and enhanced features, is an excellent choice for those looking for the latest generation of Glock technology. The Gen is a strong contender for duty use and competition shooting.
The Gen remains a strong choice and offers value.
Consider the grip feel, the importance of ambidextrous controls, and your budget when making your decision.
In Conclusion: Your Decision Matters
The Glock 17 is a legend, and both the Gen and Gen models embody its strengths. The goal of this comparison is to illuminate the key distinctions between the generations. By considering the features and advantages, you’ll be able to make an informed decision. Your needs, shooting experience, and budget will ultimately drive your choice.
If you’re still uncertain, the best advice is to try both models. Visit a local gun range or firearms retailer, and handle both models. This will allow you to experience the grip, trigger, and other features firsthand. Do more research and make a decision that aligns with your needs. Regardless of your choice, you’ll be armed with a dependable firearm.
