The S&W 686, especially in its 6-inch barrel configuration, is a powerful and iconic revolver. Known for its robust construction, impressive accuracy, and chambering in the potent .357 Magnum, it’s a favorite among sport shooters, hunters, and those seeking a reliable firearm for personal defense. However, its size and weight present a unique challenge: how to comfortably and discreetly carry this substantial handgun. This is where the shoulder holster enters the equation. This article delves into the world of shoulder holsters, specifically focusing on their suitability for the S&W 686 6-inch, offering insights to help you determine the best way to carry your firearm.
This particular handgun demands thoughtful consideration when choosing a carry method. Its weight alone necessitates a system that can properly distribute the burden. The longer barrel, while contributing to its accuracy, complicates concealment. Therefore, finding a carrying system that offers both comfortable weight distribution and concealment capabilities is essential. The shoulder holster, with its unique design, positions itself as a potential solution.
The S&W 686 6-inch represents a significant piece of hardware. It boasts a substantial frame, often constructed with stainless steel or carbon steel, contributing to its overall heft. Its barrel length adds to its impressive size. This is a gun that demands respect, and therefore, careful consideration when selecting a carry system. The ideal carry method must not only secure the firearm but also provide easy access in a moment of need. It must also maintain a degree of discretion, allowing the wearer to carry responsibly and without drawing undue attention.
The Benefits of a Shoulder Holster: A Closer Look
Shoulder holsters, unlike many other carrying systems, offer a distinctive approach to weight distribution. By suspending the firearm from the shoulders and across the back, they shift the weight away from the waist and hips. This can be a significant advantage for the S&W 686 6-inch. The revolver, due to its weight, might become a burden when carried via other methods. The shoulder holster eases this load by distributing it more evenly, potentially providing greater comfort during extended wear. This is particularly beneficial for individuals who spend a lot of time sitting, such as in a vehicle or at a desk.
Concealment is another key factor, and shoulder holsters, when used correctly, offer a good degree of discretion. The firearm is positioned beneath the arm, and can often be effectively hidden by a jacket, coat, or even a loose-fitting shirt. This allows the user to carry the S&W 686 6-inch in situations where other carry methods might be more conspicuous. The choice of clothing is critical, of course, but a well-designed shoulder holster can significantly improve concealment opportunities.
The speed of access can be another important consideration. Shoulder holsters can often provide a relatively fast and intuitive draw, depending on the design and individual training. The position of the holster allows for a natural and efficient draw stroke, enabling the user to quickly access their firearm if the need arises. The speed of access can be crucial in a self-defense scenario, so the ability to quickly access a firearm is invaluable.
Comfort, as mentioned earlier, is a central advantage. The distributed weight, combined with a well-designed harness system, often leads to a more comfortable carry experience compared to methods that place all the weight on the waist. The shoulder holster design minimizes pressure points and helps prevent the firearm from digging into the body, which can make it a suitable option for longer durations.
Navigating the Potential Drawbacks
While shoulder holsters offer numerous benefits, it’s crucial to understand their limitations before making a decision. One primary concern is concealment. While shoulder holsters can be effective, they are not universally ideal for every situation. The style of clothing that allows concealment of your S&W 686 6-inch is dependent on the holster design, and user body type. For instance, wearing a tight-fitting shirt is generally a bad idea, as it will cause the firearm to “print,” or show through the fabric. The jacket and other outer garments become essential components of the carry system and must be carefully considered when choosing to use a shoulder holster.
The potential for “printing” is a significant concern. Printing refers to the outline of the firearm being visible through clothing. This can occur with shoulder holsters if the clothing is too tight or if the holster is not properly adjusted to the wearer’s body shape. This not only compromises concealment but may also draw unwanted attention. Careful selection of clothing and proper adjustment of the holster are vital to mitigate this risk.
Another consideration is accessibility. While a well-designed shoulder holster provides relatively quick access, the draw can be complicated by certain circumstances. For example, drawing the firearm might be more difficult when seated in a vehicle if the positioning of the belt system or the jacket interferes. Practice and training are also very important to make sure your draw is quick, and accurate.
Warm weather can pose an additional challenge. Carrying a shoulder holster in hot weather can become uncomfortable. The harness and the holster itself can trap heat, leading to discomfort and potentially making concealment more difficult. In these conditions, alternative carry methods may be more practical.
Retention, or the security with which the holster holds the firearm, is paramount. A shoulder holster must securely retain the S&W 686 6-inch during movement and activity. Quality designs will incorporate retention mechanisms, such as thumb breaks, snaps, or friction locks, to prevent the firearm from accidentally falling out.
Training and practice are also very important. Like any carry system, the shoulder holster requires dedicated practice to ensure a smooth and efficient draw. Regularly practicing the draw stroke, both in a safe and controlled environment and from various positions, will help to ensure that you can access your firearm quickly and safely when it is needed.
Key Features to Look For in a Shoulder Holster
When choosing a shoulder holster for your S&W 686 6-inch, several features deserve your careful attention. The choice of material is fundamental. Leather has long been a popular material for holsters because of its durability and classic aesthetic appeal. A good quality leather holster will mold to the shape of the firearm over time, providing a custom fit and a secure hold. Leather can also be more comfortable against the skin. However, leather can be more susceptible to the elements and can require a break-in period before it reaches its full potential.
Synthetic materials like nylon or Kydex also offer viable alternatives. Nylon holsters are often more affordable and weather-resistant than leather, making them a suitable option for various conditions. Kydex, a rigid plastic material, provides excellent retention and often allows for a faster draw due to its shape. Kydex holsters are generally less prone to wear and tear than leather, but some users find them less comfortable.
The design and fit are also critical factors. Consider the cant of the holster, which is the angle at which the firearm is positioned. Different cants can affect the speed and ease of the draw and affect concealment. The harness design is also very important, as the harness is responsible for distributing the weight of the firearm. A well-designed harness will be comfortable and adjustable, providing a secure and customized fit. Look for adjustable straps that allow you to fine-tune the fit of the holster to your body shape and size.
Retention mechanisms are essential for ensuring the safety of the firearm. These mechanisms, such as thumb breaks, snaps, or friction locks, secure the firearm within the holster. These mechanisms should be secure enough to prevent the firearm from falling out during normal activities but must also allow for a quick and easy draw when needed.
The holster should be compatible with any accessories you might use, like red dot sights or weapon lights. Ensure that the holster provides adequate protection for the firearm and has the ability to attach the accessories you need.
Beyond the Shoulder Holster: Alternative Carry Methods
While a shoulder holster might be the ideal choice for some, it is important to consider the alternatives before deciding on the best method for carrying your S&W 686 6-inch. Inside the waistband (IWB) holsters provide concealment and can be comfortable for many, especially with a proper holster and belt. However, carrying a large revolver IWB can be challenging due to its size and weight, and IWB might not be the most convenient option for those who prefer to sit for extended periods.
Outside the waistband (OWB) holsters are another possibility, providing easy access and a secure carry. However, OWB carry typically requires an open-carry environment, which is regulated by state and local laws.
Chest holsters offer another option, particularly for outdoor activities like hunting or hiking. These holsters attach to the chest and provide easy access, even while wearing a backpack. This can be a good way to distribute weight and retain the firearm for ready access.
Each carry option has its own benefits and drawbacks. The ideal method ultimately depends on individual needs, preferences, and the specific circumstances in which the firearm will be carried.
Conclusion: Finding the Right Carry for Your Needs
Choosing the best carry method for your S&W 686 6-inch is a personal decision. Shoulder holsters offer a range of advantages, particularly for weight distribution and discreet carry, especially when the revolver’s substantial size is considered. They can be a comfortable and concealable solution, especially for those who spend a significant amount of time seated. However, they also come with some drawbacks, including the potential for printing and the need for careful clothing choices.
Ultimately, the best approach is to carefully consider your individual needs and circumstances. Factors such as your body type, the climate you live in, your clothing preferences, and the activities you commonly engage in will all play a role in your decision. Make sure to practice and train with any carrying method you choose. Test different holsters and carry methods before fully committing to one. This will enable you to find the carry method that is the most comfortable and effective for your needs. Research the available options, compare features, and, if possible, seek expert advice to make an informed decision. With careful consideration and selection, you can find the ideal way to carry your S&W 686 6-inch safely, comfortably, and responsibly.
