Exploring the Governor’s Core Features
The Smith & Wesson Governor. The name alone conjures images of authority, control, and, for some, a touch of the unconventional. Is it a handgun? A compact shotgun? The Governor has certainly sparked debate since its release, a gun that challenges convention and caters to a specific niche in the vast landscape of firearms. But does its unique design and multi-caliber capabilities translate to real-world effectiveness? Is the S&W Governor truly worth the investment, or is it simply a novelty item that falls short of its ambitious claims?
This article will delve into the depths of the S&W Governor, dissecting its features, evaluating its strengths, and highlighting its weaknesses. We’ll explore its performance in various scenarios and compare it to other options on the market. Our aim is to equip you with the information needed to make an informed decision: Is the S&W Governor a worthy addition to your collection or, perhaps, a tool you’d be better off leaving on the shelf?
A Symphony of Calibers: The Ammunition Arsenal
One of the Governor’s defining characteristics is its remarkable ability to chamber multiple ammunition types. It’s engineered to fire .45 Colt, .45 ACP, and even 2.75-inch .410 shotshells. This flexibility is a significant selling point, offering the user a range of options depending on the situation and their preferences.
The .45 Colt, a cartridge with a long and storied history, delivers impressive stopping power. It’s known for its large diameter and ability to generate considerable energy. .45 ACP, a staple in the world of semi-automatic pistols, provides similar power levels and the added benefit of wider ammunition availability and lower cost. The .410 shotshell, a more controversial choice for a handgun, brings the potential of a spread pattern, theoretically making it easier to hit a target at close range.
The Governor’s versatility, however, comes with some caveats. To fire .45 ACP rounds, you must use moon clips. These small metal devices hold the cartridges together, as .45 ACP is rimless and does not naturally eject from a revolver cylinder. Moon clips add another step to the reloading process and can be cumbersome for some.
Construction and the Feel of the Grip
The Governor is typically constructed with a stainless-steel frame and cylinder, providing durability and resistance to corrosion. The finish is often a matte black or stainless steel, adding to its rugged appearance. The size, however, means it’s not intended for pocket carry.
The grips are designed to provide a secure and comfortable hold. The standard grips are often made of a polymer or synthetic material that offers a good balance of grip and durability. Some aftermarket options are available, giving you the opportunity to customize the feel and appearance of your Governor. The size of the gun ensures a solid grip.
Sights, Action, and Operation
The Governor typically features a fixed or adjustable sight system. While a fixed system is simpler and faster to use, adjustable sights can be useful for fine-tuning the point of impact with different ammunition types. The sight picture, however, will depend on the user and how their eyes adjust to the sight.
The Governor operates with either a double-action/single-action (DA/SA) or double-action only (DAO) trigger mechanism, depending on the model. The DAO trigger means that each pull of the trigger both cocks and releases the hammer, which results in a longer, heavier trigger pull. In a DA/SA configuration, the first shot is double-action, while subsequent shots can be fired single-action (after the hammer has been cocked). This setup can offer a smoother, lighter trigger pull for follow-up shots. The trigger action is a key factor in the firearm’s overall feel and shootability.
The cylinder of the Governor typically holds six rounds, a standard capacity for many revolvers. This capacity is often compared to pistols, so the shooter must consider what is considered effective and the need for more rounds.
The Governor’s Advantages
Let’s delve into the strengths of this interesting revolver.
The Power of Multi-Caliber Function
The Governor’s ability to chamber three different cartridge types is arguably its most significant advantage. This versatility means you can choose the most appropriate ammunition for the situation. Whether you prefer the raw power of .45 Colt, the commonality of .45 ACP, or the spread pattern of a .410 shotshell, the Governor provides the option. This adaptability could be a valuable asset for someone who wants a single handgun that can adapt to different environments.
Stopping Power and Potential
The .45 Colt and .45 ACP cartridges are known for their ability to effectively neutralize threats. Their large bullet diameters and substantial energy levels provide the potential for significant stopping power. While the debate about “stopping power” is ongoing, the Governor’s ability to fire these rounds offers a degree of assurance in a self-defense scenario. The user must know that the gun provides a great level of safety, if the firearm is used with proficiency.
The .410 Shotgun (Debated)
The inclusion of .410 shotshell capability is a point of contention among firearms enthusiasts. The effectiveness of a .410 shotshell fired from a handgun is often questioned, given the limited range and the potential for a less dense shot pattern compared to a full-sized shotgun. The pattern is important, but can create issues for the user.
Revolver Reliability
Revolvers, in general, are known for their reliability. Their simple designs and fewer moving parts compared to semi-automatic pistols often translate to fewer opportunities for malfunctions. The Governor, with its rugged construction and dependable design, is a strong contender in this regard, offering a level of assurance that some shooters value.
Build Quality and Durability
The stainless-steel construction of the Governor contributes to its durability and longevity. The gun’s overall build quality suggests it is designed to withstand the rigors of regular use. This robust construction should provide a long service life with proper care and maintenance.
The Governor’s Challenges
Now let’s look at the drawbacks that potential buyers must keep in mind.
Size, Weight, and Concealability
The Governor’s substantial size and weight present a significant challenge for concealed carry. The large frame makes it difficult to conceal comfortably. The weight can be fatiguing for everyday carry. The Governor is far easier to carry in a holster, but the size is still a factor.
Magazine Limits
The six-round capacity of the cylinder is a point of consideration. While this is a common capacity for revolvers, it is less than some semi-automatic pistols chambered in similar calibers. The reload time for a revolver can also be slower than that of a semi-automatic pistol.
.410 Shotgun Effectiveness (Again)
The .410 shotshell, fired from a handgun, has a limited effective range. The shot pattern disperses quickly, making it difficult to achieve a decisive hit beyond close quarters. The .410 loads are not recommended for self-defense due to their limitations.
Recoil and Control
The Governor can produce significant recoil, especially when firing .45 Colt or .45 ACP rounds. The heavy recoil can make follow-up shots more challenging, requiring more practice and experience to maintain accuracy and control.
Price Considerations
The price of the S&W Governor is another factor to consider. While the price varies depending on the retailer and any included accessories, the Governor can be more expensive than some comparable firearms. This is something that potential buyers must understand and know before they buy the firearm.
Performance in Real-World Scenarios
The theoretical advantages of a firearm must translate into practical effectiveness. Here is how the Governor performs.
Accuracy Assessment
Accuracy tests with the Governor typically show that the firearm is capable of acceptable groups at typical handgun engagement distances. The gun must be handled with care, but experienced shooters are usually able to make a good shot. The results will vary depending on the ammunition used and the shooter’s skill.
Concealed Carry Perspective
Due to its size and weight, the Governor presents challenges for concealed carry. While it is possible to conceal the Governor with the right holster and clothing, it may not be the most comfortable or practical option for everyday carry.
Home Defense Considerations
The Governor could be a viable option for home defense. Its power, reliability, and ease of use make it a strong choice. The shooter must evaluate how their home is set up and if it is the right tool for the job. The user must have the experience necessary to use the gun if the need arises.
Comparing Alternatives
To make a truly informed decision, it’s important to compare the Governor to its competitors.
Other .45 ACP Pistols
Semi-automatic pistols chambered in .45 ACP offer similar levels of power. Pistols, such as the Glock 21 or a 1911-style handgun, typically have larger magazine capacities, are often easier to conceal. The choice between a revolver and a semi-automatic is often down to personal preference.
Considering Other Revolvers
Other Smith & Wesson revolvers chambered in .45 Colt or .45 ACP offer similar ballistic performance, with varying features and sizes.
Alternative Concealed Carry Options
If concealability is a primary concern, there are many smaller, lighter handguns that may be better suited for concealed carry. These guns may offer a greater balance of power.
The Final Verdict
So, is the S&W Governor worth it? The answer, like with any firearm, is complex and depends heavily on your individual needs and priorities.
The Governor shines in its versatility, offering the ability to chamber three different cartridge types and providing a powerful combination of stopping power. The revolver design offers solid reliability and build quality.
However, its size and weight make concealed carry difficult. The .410 shotshell performance is questionable, and the recoil can be significant. The six-round capacity may not be adequate for everyone.
Ultimately, the S&W Governor is a niche firearm. It might be a good fit for individuals who value the versatility of multiple calibers. It may also appeal to those who appreciate the reliability of a revolver. It’s not the best choice for those looking for a truly concealable handgun or a firearm that excels in its .410 performance.
If you prioritize versatility and appreciate the unique design, the S&W Governor could be a good choice. If concealment and handling are of greater importance, there are better options available. Carefully consider your own needs and preferences before making a decision.
