Introduction
Owning a Smith & Wesson Model 19 is more than just owning a firearm; it’s owning a piece of history, a symbol of craftsmanship, and a versatile tool for both personal defense and recreational shooting. This classic revolver, known for its .357 Magnum capabilities in a mid-sized frame, has earned its place as a favorite among shooters for generations. However, the best S&W Model 19 deserves the best holster. A well-chosen holster is not merely an accessory; it’s a vital piece of equipment that directly impacts safety, comfort, and the efficiency of your draw. This comprehensive guide will navigate the world of holsters, providing you with the knowledge to select the perfect holster for your specific needs and your cherished S&W Model 19.
The journey to finding the right holster begins with understanding the crucial factors that shape your choice. From carry style to material, from retention to concealability, each element plays a significant role in the overall performance and suitability of a holster. Let’s delve into the critical considerations.
Understanding Carry Styles
The style of carry you choose will often define which holster styles are even in play. Choosing your carry style is a crucial decision, as it dictates how you’ll carry your Model 19 and directly influences comfort, concealability, and accessibility. Different carry styles cater to distinct needs and preferences.
Inside the Waistband (IWB) holsters are designed to be concealed within the waistband of your pants. This method prioritizes concealment, making it an excellent choice for everyday carry (EDC) in various environments. IWB holsters come in various positions (appendix, strong-side, behind the hip), allowing you to customize the carry position to match your body type and preferences. While offering excellent concealment, IWB holsters can sometimes compromise comfort, especially with a larger firearm like the Model 19.
Outside the Waistband (OWB) holsters are worn outside the waistband, offering a more accessible and comfortable carry option, especially for extended periods. OWB holsters are often favored for range days, open carry, or when concealment is not a primary concern. They can provide easier access to the firearm compared to IWB options, making them suitable for situations where a quick draw is necessary. However, OWB holsters are less concealable, potentially requiring an untucked shirt or a jacket.
For those who prioritize security and accessibility, a chest holster might be a good option, especially for outdoor activities. This holster is designed to be carried across the chest, offering quick access while also keeping the firearm secure.
Shoulder holsters, popular in the past, are still chosen by some. These holsters distribute the weight of the firearm across the shoulders, potentially improving comfort, especially with a heavier gun like the Model 19. They are often used when seated for extended periods.
Ultimately, the best carry style depends on your lifestyle, attire, and specific needs. Consider factors such as concealment requirements, comfort, accessibility, and intended use when making your choice.
Materials Matter
The material used in a holster profoundly influences its durability, comfort, and overall performance.
Leather holsters are a timeless classic, known for their comfort, durability, and aesthetic appeal. Leather conforms to the shape of the firearm over time, providing a custom fit. They exude a classic look that many shooters find appealing. Leather is naturally breathable, contributing to wearer comfort, especially in warmer climates. However, leather requires break-in to achieve a comfortable fit. Leather holsters also require regular maintenance, including cleaning and conditioning, to prevent drying and cracking. They can be susceptible to moisture damage, requiring care to avoid rust on the firearm.
Kydex holsters offer a modern alternative, prized for their rigidity, retention, and resistance to the elements. Kydex is a thermoplastic material that is molded to the exact specifications of the firearm, providing secure retention. It’s highly resistant to moisture, making it a good choice for humid environments or outdoor use. Kydex is generally low maintenance, requiring only occasional cleaning. However, Kydex holsters often lack the inherent comfort of leather and can potentially wear the finish of your firearm due to the hard surface.
Nylon/Synthetic holsters provide an affordable option, often favored for their lightweight construction. These holsters are often inexpensive, making them accessible to a wide range of users. However, nylon holsters can be less durable and offer less secure retention compared to leather or Kydex. They are also more prone to collapse when the firearm is drawn, potentially hindering re-holstering and can sometimes lack the refined look. They are best suited for casual use or range days.
Understanding Retention Levels
Retention is critical for preventing accidental firearm discharge. The level of retention your holster offers should align with your intended use and carry style.
Level one retention typically relies on friction to hold the firearm in place. These holsters are often used for concealed carry, where a balance between retention and quick access is desired. The retention relies on the fit of the holster or a simple tensioning screw.
Level two retention adds a secondary locking mechanism, often a thumb break or a retention device. These holsters are commonly used by law enforcement and security professionals, offering increased security and preventing unauthorized access.
Level three retention employs multiple locking mechanisms for maximum security. These holsters are designed for high-risk situations, military use, or environments where the potential for gun grabs is high.
Consider your environment and potential threats when selecting a retention level. For everyday concealed carry, a holster with good friction and a tight fit may suffice. For duty use, a holster with multiple levels of retention is usually preferred.
Prioritizing Comfort and Concealment
A holster’s comfort directly affects how frequently you’ll carry your Model 19. A comfortable holster encourages consistent carry, increasing your personal safety.
Choose a holster with a design that evenly distributes weight. The holster profile should be as slim as possible, and the materials should be comfortable against your skin. The holster’s cant (angle) and ride height can also affect comfort and concealability, influencing the placement of the holster on the belt.
Concealability refers to the holster’s ability to hide the firearm from view. This is heavily impacted by the holster’s design and the firearm. The cant, ride height, and profile of the holster directly influence how well the firearm conceals under clothing. The material of the holster matters, as it will often directly impact the size and form factor.
Durability, Quality and Budget
Building quality directly impacts the lifespan and performance of a holster. Look for holsters made from high-quality materials, featuring reinforced stitching, and durable hardware. Carefully examine the holster for any weaknesses or flaws.
A durable holster is a long-term investment that protects your firearm and provides years of reliable service. Evaluate the overall construction, paying attention to the details that define quality.
Holster prices can range from affordable to premium. Decide on your budget and set realistic expectations. Consider the value you receive for your investment. It’s best to spend a little more for a durable holster that offers excellent functionality, retention, and comfort.
Top Holster Recommendations
These are just a few recommendations to help you find the ideal holster for your S&W Model 19.
Inside the Waistband (IWB) Recommendation
The **Galco Combat Master** is an excellent IWB option made from premium steerhide leather, delivering excellent comfort and a secure fit. It provides a smooth draw and re-holstering. The Combat Master is designed for strong-side carry, ensuring excellent concealment while maintaining a high degree of comfort. The open-top design allows for a fast draw.
Outside the Waistband (OWB) Recommendation
The **Safariland Model 7378 7TS™ ALS® Concealment Paddle Holster** is a great choice for an OWB holster. Constructed from SafariSeven, a proprietary nylon blend, this holster provides excellent durability and resistance to extreme temperatures. The ALS (Automatic Locking System) provides a secure retention that’s very easy to use. The open-top design allows for a quick draw.
Concealed Carry Holster Recommendation
The **Vedder Holsters ProDraw OWB Holster** is another great option for OWB carry. Vedder Holsters are made from Kydex, ensuring a secure and reliable platform. The ProDraw offers a variety of features, including adjustable cant and ride height, which contributes to the customization of the holster.
Duty/Tactical Holster Recommendation
For duty or tactical use, consider the **Safariland 6378USN ALS® Concealment Paddle Holster**. This holster offers excellent security with its ALS (Automatic Locking System) retention. Constructed from durable materials, this holster is built to withstand the rigors of daily use. The paddle design allows for quick attachment and detachment.
Other Holster Type Recommendation
The **Alien Gear ShapeShift Chest Holster** is a unique and comfortable way to carry a Model 19 while enjoying outdoor activities. This chest holster provides excellent concealment and accessibility. The ShapeShift allows you to carry the Model 19 securely and comfortably.
Comparison Table
| Holster Name | Carry Style | Material | Retention Level | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Galco Combat Master | IWB | Premium Leather | Level 1 | Comfortable, concealed, smooth draw | Requires break-in |
| Safariland 7378 7TS™ ALS® Paddle | OWB | SafariSeven | Level 2 | Durable, weather resistant, excellent retention | May require a larger belt for stability |
| Vedder Holsters ProDraw | OWB | Kydex | Level 1 | Secure, adjustable, customizable | Kydex can be less comfortable than leather |
| Safariland 6378USN ALS® | Duty/Tactical | SafariSeven | Level 2 | Extremely secure, rugged, reliable | May require specialized training for use |
| Alien Gear ShapeShift Chest Holster | Chest | Kydex/Fabric | Level 1 | Comfortable, accessible, good concealment during outdoor activity | May not be ideal for concealed carry |
Holster Care and Maintenance
Regular maintenance is essential to extend the life of your holster.
For leather holsters, apply leather conditioner regularly to prevent cracking and maintain flexibility. Clean the leather with a mild soap and water solution when necessary.
Kydex holsters require minimal maintenance, but they should be cleaned regularly to remove dirt and debris.
For all holsters, regularly inspect for wear and tear. Store your holster in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight.
Where to Purchase
Browse the official websites of holster manufacturers (e.g., Galco, Safariland, Vedder Holsters, Alien Gear Holsters). You may also find some on other reputable online retailers such as Amazon or MidwayUSA. Local gun stores can often offer valuable guidance and fitting services.
Conclusion
Choosing the best holster for your S&W Model 19 is an investment in your safety, comfort, and your ability to effectively carry and use your firearm. Take the time to research, compare, and try out different options to find the perfect holster that meets your individual needs. Prioritize factors such as carry style, material, retention, comfort, concealability, and build quality. By making an informed decision, you can ensure that your Model 19 remains readily accessible and secure when you need it most. Choosing the right holster enhances your experience as a responsible gun owner.
