Introduction
Beretta over-and-under shotguns are synonymous with quality, reliability, and performance in the shooting world. They are a mainstay for clay shooters, hunters, and enthusiasts worldwide, offering a blend of elegant design and robust functionality. Among the most popular and respected models are the 686 and 687 series. These shotguns have earned a reputation for excellence, but they differ in key aspects that appeal to different shooters.
This article aims to provide a detailed comparison of the Beretta 686 and 687 series shotguns, exploring their history, features, performance, and value. Whether you’re a seasoned competitor or a newcomer to the sport, understanding the nuances of each series will assist you in making an informed decision when choosing your next over-and-under. This comprehensive comparison aims to assist you in your quest to discover the best Beretta shotgun for your individual shooting style and needs, and explore the factors that ultimately separate the two.
A Look Back at the Beretta 686 Series
The Beretta 686 series, first introduced in the early 1980s, quickly established itself as a workhorse in the world of shotguns. Its primary appeal was a perfect balance of reliability, affordability, and performance. It was designed with a focus on being a durable and dependable firearm, capable of withstanding the rigors of both competitive shooting and field hunting.
The 686 series is built upon a robust action, employing a low-profile receiver design that contributes to its overall balance and pointability. This design offers a streamlined aesthetic and often proves more comfortable for shooters of varying builds. Early models were offered at attractive price points, making them accessible to a wide range of shooters.
The 686 series has spawned numerous variants over the years, catering to different shooting disciplines and preferences. Some popular models include the 686 Silver Pigeon I, known for its classic styling and excellent value. Other variations, like the 686 Sporting and 686 White Onyx, further showcase the versatility of the design, with features designed to optimize performance in different sports. This versatility is one reason why the Beretta 686 remains a popular choice.
Understanding the Beretta 687 Series
The Beretta 687 series represents an evolution of the 686 platform. It embodies a step up in terms of aesthetics, finishing, and often, enhanced features. Generally, the 687 is seen as a more refined and upgraded version of the 686. The 687 series aims to provide a high-end shooting experience, emphasizing finer details and premium materials.
The 687 models feature enhanced stock woodwork, with higher-grade walnut often selected for the stocks and forends. The checkering on the wood is usually finer, enhancing the grip and tactile feel. The engraving on the receiver is typically more elaborate, adding a touch of elegance and sophistication to the overall appearance. The 687 represents an investment in terms of aesthetic craftsmanship.
Like the 686, the 687 series offers a range of models designed for specific applications. Models like the 687 Silver Pigeon III, the 687 Sporting, and 687 EELL all exemplify the series’ commitment to quality and performance. These guns cater to shooters who want a premium feel and a touch of luxury in their shotgun. The refined appearance also sets the 687 apart.
Core Differences: Construction and Engineering
One of the crucial aspects to consider when comparing the two series is the fundamental build and design. The receiver construction and materials used directly affect the shotgun’s durability, weight, and longevity. These fundamental differences in design also impact the shooting experience.
The receivers, while similar in design, often feature different materials and finishes. Many 686 models utilize a steel receiver, which provides excellent strength and durability. Higher-end models may use alloy receivers. The 687 series, on the other hand, often employs a steel receiver and typically comes with more refined finishes, such as polished bluing or color case hardening.
The action of the shotguns, which refers to the mechanical system that loads, fires, and ejects shells, is a key differentiator. Both the 686 and 687 series utilize Beretta’s proven over-and-under design with a similar locking mechanism. The 687 often features refinements to the action and smoother operation, which enhance the overall shooting experience. These modifications are often subtle but contribute significantly to the feel.
Ejectors also showcase a difference between the two series. The 686 generally uses a reliable and functional ejector system. The 687, however, can use a more sophisticated ejector design, such as automatic ejectors, which provide enhanced ejection and a more seamless reloading process.
Key Features and Differentiating Aspects
Beyond the structural foundation, the features are essential. These features affect the appearance and functionality of the gun, and contribute to its overall feel and performance.
The woodwork plays a big part in the overall impression of a shotgun. The wood grade and finishing are often an area where the 687 series excels. The 687 often uses premium grade walnut, which is carefully selected for its figure and grain. The checkering is finer, providing a superior grip and aesthetic appeal. The finishing on the wood is often more labor-intensive, resulting in a richer, more lustrous finish. The 686, while still employing quality wood, typically uses a less elaborate grade, and the finishing may be simpler.
The barrels, critical for accuracy and performance, are also an area of differentiation. Both the 686 and 687 often employ Beretta’s proven barrel technology. However, the 687 may have barrels with improved internal geometry, or be paired with high-grade chokes. This can lead to improved shot patterns and target breaking ability. These differences are often subtle but can impact the overall shooting experience.
The trigger and safety mechanisms can showcase refinements in the 687. The trigger pull may be crisper and lighter, providing better control and responsiveness. The safety mechanisms, although similar in design, may be constructed with higher-grade materials and be more refined in their operation. The trigger feel can significantly impact the shooting performance.
Handling and balance contribute significantly to the overall enjoyment of shooting. The 686 often has a well-balanced feel, making it easy to point and swing. The 687, with its enhanced woodwork, weight distribution, and finer details, can often feel more refined and responsive in the hands. It’s vital to shoulder and swing both guns to see which one fits you best.
Customization options also matter. While both series offer many accessories, the 687 might offer greater flexibility. Different barrel lengths, choke types, and stock dimensions are often readily available. This allows shooters to customize the gun to their specific needs and preferences.
Evaluating Performance: Comparing Results
The true test of any shotgun is its performance on the range or in the field. Looking at the reliability, shooting experience, and suitability for different uses is paramount.
Both the 686 and 687 series are known for their reliability. Beretta’s reputation for building durable and dependable firearms extends to both series. However, the 687, with its more refined engineering, might experience slightly smoother operation over time. The overall reliability of each shotgun speaks to Beretta’s history of building quality firearms.
The shooting experience varies between the two. The 686, with its functional design, provides a solid and enjoyable shooting experience. The 687 often offers a more premium feel, with a smoother action, a crisper trigger pull, and enhanced aesthetics. This can contribute to increased comfort and satisfaction during extended shooting sessions.
Suitability for different shooting sports must be assessed. The 686, with its versatility, is suitable for various disciplines, including sporting clays, skeet, and hunting. The 687, with its premium features, often shines in sporting clays and other competitive environments, where the shooter can appreciate the refined action and aesthetics. The best gun for you depends on the discipline.
Longevity and durability are also important. Both series are designed to last for many years with proper care and maintenance. The 687, with its higher-grade materials and finishing, may potentially offer a slightly longer lifespan, but both series will provide decades of service. Both shotguns are a significant investment and require regular care.
Price, Value, and the Bottom Line
A thorough evaluation of price and value is essential before making any purchase.
The pricing of the 686 and 687 series varies depending on the model, condition, and any additional features. Generally, the 686 series is priced lower than the 687 series, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious shooters. The 687, due to its premium features and finishes, typically carries a higher price tag.
The value proposition depends on individual priorities. The 686 offers excellent value for its reliability and performance. The 687 offers a higher level of craftsmanship and luxury. The best value for you will depend on your needs.
The price also fluctuates based on factors like the grade of wood used, the condition of the gun, and the rarity of the model. Used 686 models can offer an even better value, providing an excellent entry point into the world of Beretta over-and-unders.
Advantages and Disadvantages: A Summary
Summarizing the pros and cons of each series can help to clarify your choices.
The 686 series offers several advantages, including affordability, reliability, and ease of maintenance. Its robust design and versatile performance make it an excellent all-around choice. However, some shooters may find the aesthetics less refined than the 687 series.
The 687 series offers distinct advantages. Its enhanced aesthetics, superior wood, and more refined features appeal to discerning shooters. The smoother action and crisper trigger can contribute to a more enjoyable shooting experience. The 687, however, comes with a higher price tag.
Choosing the Right Series for You
The best series depends on your individual shooting style and preferences. Consider what is right for you.
The 686 series is ideal for beginners, those on a budget, and shooters who prioritize reliability and functionality. Its robust design and reasonable price make it an excellent choice for all levels.
The 687 series is recommended for experienced shooters, those seeking premium features and aesthetics, and those willing to invest more in their shotgun. Its refined features and enhanced craftsmanship provide a superior shooting experience.
The choice also depends on your specific needs. If you’re primarily interested in sporting clays, the 687 might be a better choice. For all-around use, the 686 can be perfect.
Conclusion: Making the Right Decision
The Beretta 686 and 687 series shotguns are both excellent choices for those looking for a quality over-and-under. The 686 offers a solid combination of reliability, performance, and affordability, while the 687 elevates the shooting experience with premium features and refined aesthetics.
Ultimately, the best choice comes down to individual needs, preferences, and budget. Carefully consider the features of each series, handle and evaluate both guns if possible, and select the shotgun that best suits your shooting style. This way, you’ll find the perfect shotgun for you.
Further Resources
Visit the official Beretta website to explore the current product line.
Consult online gun review sites and forums for unbiased opinions and comparisons.
Contact local gun shops and shooting ranges to try out both the 686 and 687 shotguns.
