Why Choose a Revolver for Concealed Carry?
The crack of the door in the dead of night. The glint of metal in the dim light. These are the moments for which responsible individuals prepare. The ability to protect oneself and loved ones is a fundamental right, and for many, that protection starts with the reliable presence of a concealed handgun. While the world of concealed carry offers numerous options, one weapon system continues to hold a unique appeal: the revolver. For decades, the revolver has provided a sense of security, simplicity, and power that has made it a trusted companion for self-defense. So, what is the best revolver for concealed carry? Let’s explore the essential factors and delve into some of the top contenders.
The appeal of the revolver in the realm of concealed carry is rooted in its core design. Simplicity reigns supreme. Unlike semi-automatic pistols, revolvers often lack complex manual safeties and intricate slide manipulations. This simplicity translates to ease of use, a crucial element when under pressure. In a high-stress situation, the instinctive draw and firing of a revolver can provide an advantage. No fumbling with safeties, no need to rack the slide – just point and pull the trigger.
Moreover, revolvers boast a reputation for unwavering reliability. Their robust construction and relatively simple mechanics often lead to fewer malfunctions compared to their semi-automatic counterparts. While semi-automatics are undeniably advancing in reliability, the core design of the revolver inherently reduces the number of moving parts that can potentially fail. For those prioritizing a weapon that is extremely likely to function when needed, the revolver offers a compelling argument.
The inherent power of a revolver cannot be ignored. Many revolvers are chambered in potent calibers like .38 Special and .357 Magnum, delivering considerable stopping power. These rounds are renowned for their energy and effectiveness in self-defense situations. The psychological impact of the report and recoil can also be a deterrent.
Finally, the slim profile of certain revolver models, coupled with their inherent safety features, makes them conducive to concealed carry. The rounded frames and lack of sharp edges contribute to a more comfortable and discreet carry experience. They are also easy to maintain. The components are generally less complex, which means fewer things can go wrong, and cleaning is usually a straightforward process.
However, the revolver isn’t without its drawbacks. The most notable disadvantage is the limited ammunition capacity compared to many semi-automatic pistols. A standard revolver typically holds five to six rounds, while a semi-automatic can carry significantly more. This lower capacity necessitates careful shot placement and a disciplined approach to defensive scenarios.
Reloading a revolver is also generally slower than reloading a semi-automatic. The process of refilling the cylinder, whether using speedloaders or individual rounds, takes longer than the swift magazine changes of a semi-automatic.
The heavier trigger pull common in many revolvers, particularly double-action models, can affect accuracy, requiring dedicated practice to master. The higher recoil generated by many of the calibers used in revolvers, such as the .357 magnum, can also be challenging for some shooters, especially those new to firearms.
Key Considerations When Choosing a Concealed Carry Revolver
Before selecting a best revolver for concealed carry, several crucial factors must be carefully considered.
One of the most critical decisions involves caliber. The choice of caliber is inextricably linked to stopping power, recoil, ammunition availability, and personal comfort. Popular options for concealed carry revolvers include .38 Special, .357 Magnum, .327 Federal Magnum, and even .22 Long Rifle in certain applications.
The .38 Special is a classic choice, offering a good balance of manageable recoil and effective stopping power. Ammunition is readily available, and revolvers chambered in this caliber are often more compact.
The .357 Magnum is a powerhouse, delivering significant energy and terminal performance. However, it produces considerably more recoil than the .38 Special, making it less ideal for novice shooters. The .357 Magnum is a versatile choice, as it can also safely fire .38 Special rounds, providing the option of reduced recoil during practice.
The .327 Federal Magnum is a more recent development, providing high velocity and excellent penetration with less recoil than the .357 Magnum. The recoil is manageable and can be a good choice for concealed carry.
.22 LR revolvers, while offering minimal recoil and being relatively inexpensive to shoot, have less stopping power, making them less ideal for self-defense.
The size and weight of the revolver are paramount for effective concealed carry. The ideal balance is found by carefully weighing concealability against shootability. A smaller, lighter revolver is easier to conceal but may be more challenging to control during rapid fire due to increased recoil and a smaller grip. Larger, heavier revolvers may be more comfortable to shoot but are more difficult to conceal. Consider how you intend to carry the revolver – pocket, inside the waistband (IWB), or outside the waistband (OWB) – when assessing the suitability of a specific model.
The trigger is another vital consideration. Revolvers typically operate with either a double-action/single-action (DA/SA) trigger or a double-action-only (DAO) trigger. In a DA/SA revolver, the first trigger pull cocks and releases the hammer, while subsequent shots can be fired with a lighter pull. A DAO trigger requires the hammer to be cocked with each trigger pull, resulting in a consistently heavier pull. The trigger pull weight and smoothness are crucial factors impacting accuracy. A smooth, consistent trigger pull is vital for precise shot placement.
The sights are also important. The visibility of the sights and ease of acquiring your target will influence accuracy in any defensive situation. Fixed sights are common on smaller revolvers, while adjustable sights may be found on larger models. Fixed sights offer simplicity and durability, but adjustable sights provide the ability to fine-tune the point of impact for greater precision.
The grip of the revolver directly affects comfort and control. The grip should fit comfortably in the hand and provide a secure purchase. Grip materials range from wood to rubber, with rubber grips often offering better recoil absorption.
Choosing the right method of concealment is key. Options include IWB (Inside the Waistband), OWB (Outside the Waistband), pocket carry, and ankle carry. Each method has its advantages and disadvantages. The most common methods are IWB and OWB. IWB holsters offer better concealment but can be less comfortable for some. OWB holsters are generally more comfortable but may require a larger garment to conceal the firearm. The method you choose needs to work with your body type, your wardrobe, and your lifestyle.
Top Revolver Recommendations for Concealed Carry
Now, let’s look at some of the best revolvers for concealed carry, taking into account the various factors discussed.
Small, Lightweight Revolvers
For those seeking a compact and easily concealable option, small, lightweight revolvers are ideal. These are often referred to as J-frame revolvers, named after the frame size.
The Smith & Wesson Model 642 is a prime example. This lightweight snub-nose revolver chambered in .38 Special, weighing in at approximately 15 ounces, and featuring a five-round cylinder, it is easy to conceal. Its simplicity, with a DAO trigger, makes it user-friendly. The lightweight design and hammerless configuration contribute to its concealability, allowing for easy pocket carry or IWB carry. However, the short barrel and lightweight frame can make it challenging to control during rapid fire. It is an excellent choice for those prioritizing maximum concealability and ease of carry.
Another excellent option in this category is the Ruger LCR (Lightweight Carry Revolver). This revolver, typically chambered in .38 Special, .357 Magnum, or other calibers, uses a polymer fire control housing, and a lightweight aluminum or stainless steel frame. Its streamlined design and DAO trigger make it user-friendly. The LCR’s lightweight design and compact dimensions lend themselves well to concealed carry. The trigger pull on the LCR is usually known for being a little smoother than on the S&W 642. These revolvers are best for individuals who want to make the gun disappear when concealed.
Mid-Size Revolvers
Moving up in size, mid-size revolvers provide a balance between concealability and shootability. K-frame and smaller L-frame models from Smith & Wesson often fall into this category.
The Smith & Wesson Model 686, a classic K-frame revolver, presents a strong case. This model, typically chambered in .357 Magnum (and also capable of firing .38 Special), offers a six- or seven-round cylinder, and a heavier, more robust frame than J-frame models. This heavier frame helps to mitigate recoil, making it easier to control during rapid fire. The Model 686 is available with various barrel lengths. The longer barrel versions are better for range performance, while shorter barrel versions are better for concealed carry. While not as easy to conceal as the smaller J-frame revolvers, the Model 686 offers an excellent balance of power, accuracy, and shootability. It is well-suited for those willing to trade some concealability for improved control and a larger ammunition capacity.
For concealed carry, the Smith & Wesson 686 Plus, featuring a seven-round cylinder, is a good choice.
Pocket Revolvers
Finally, let’s consider the pocket revolver category.
.22LR and .38 Special models that can be easily concealed in a pocket are popular choices.
Accessories to Consider
When choosing a best revolver for concealed carry, consider the accessories.
The holster is a critical component of any concealed carry setup. The type of holster (IWB, OWB, pocket, or ankle) depends on the firearm, the clothing worn, and individual preferences. Holster materials range from leather to Kydex, each offering different advantages. Kydex holsters often provide superior retention and are easier to clean, while leather holsters offer a classic look and feel. Choose a holster that provides a secure fit, covers the trigger guard, and prevents accidental discharge.
Carrying the right ammunition is a critical component. Choose the right bullet type, like JHP (Jacketed Hollow Point) bullets are designed to expand upon impact, delivering maximum stopping power. Selecting the appropriate ammunition is vital for self-defense. Ensure that the ammunition you select functions reliably in your chosen revolver and that you practice with it regularly.
Speed loaders or speed strips can significantly improve reloading speed. These devices hold multiple rounds, allowing you to replenish the cylinder quickly. Speed loaders typically release all rounds simultaneously, while speed strips allow you to load individual rounds. While these accessories add to the overall bulk, they can be essential when reloading under pressure.
Safety and Training
However, remember that concealed carry comes with significant responsibility. Prioritize gun safety by storing your firearm securely and always treating every firearm as if it were loaded. Attend a recognized firearms training course. Consider the local concealed carry laws that vary from state to state.
Conclusion
Ultimately, selecting the best revolver for concealed carry is a personal decision. Take the time to thoroughly research your options, consider your specific needs and preferences, and handle various models before making a final choice. The best option is the one that you will carry and practice with consistently.
In summary, the best revolver for concealed carry is one that balances concealability, shootability, and reliability. Consider your own individual preferences, skill level, and lifestyle when making your selection. Consider the calibers, the weight, and the grip.
Remember, safe gun handling and responsible ownership are paramount. Seek professional training to develop proficiency and ensure compliance with all local laws and regulations. Visit a local gun store to handle different revolvers, test out various holster configurations, and get advice from experienced professionals. Consistent practice with your chosen firearm and ammunition is critical for developing the skills and confidence to handle a self-defense situation effectively. Be safe and be prepared.
